Read the chapter · All chapters

Why We Have a Butt

The Glute Training Magazine, Chapter 3. Animated pilot, 2 minutes 37 seconds.

CHAPTER 3 OF 8
1972 to 2006

Why We Have a Butt

Three scientists, three answers, and one treadmill that changed the answer.

Booty Center peach
Skeletons of apes and man, Huxley, 1863 · Public domain
THE PUZZLEWhy did ours change? For over a hundred years, the usual answer did not hold up.
upper part
lower part: most of the muscle
Ape
upper part: much bigger and thicker
lower part: gone
Human
Georges Cuvier · Wellcome Collection, CC BY 4.0
THE OLD IDEA
Georges Cuvier
Wrote that man is the only animal with true buttocks.
1800
The big human glute is for standing upright and walking.

It sounded obvious. But nobody had recorded the muscle at work.

1950s AND 1960s: THE FIRST RECORDINGS

Scientists put electrodes on the muscle and watched the signal.

Standing
Walking

Almost silent.

JS
Jack Stern
Anatomist. Compared the muscle across primates.
1972

What is unique in humans is the upper part.

1Thicker than in any other primate
2A new, firm origin
3A new attachment into the side of the thigh
HIS READINGIt keeps the trunk from tipping sideways.
MM
Mary Marzke
Anthropologist. Recorded the muscle in six people.
1988

She tested the things early humans did with tools.

Throw
Strike
Dig
Lift

Bars illustrate her description, not her measured values.

HER READINGIt controls the trunk when we throw, strike, dig and lift.
Throwing and heaving, Muybridge, 1887 · Public domain
YOUR TURN

So what is it really built for?

Tap your guess. The film waits for you.

DL
Daniel Lieberman
Harvard University. Recorded the muscle on a treadmill.
2006
Walking: mostly quiet

Same person, same muscle. The signal only wakes up when the walk becomes a run.

IN RUNNING, IT DOES TWO JOBS
A man running, photographed by Eadweard Muybridge, 1887 · Public domain
JOB 1It stops the trunk from tipping forward when the foot lands.
JOB 2It slows the swinging leg.

Three answers to one question

1972 · STERNIt keeps the trunk from tipping sideways.
1988 · MARZKEIt controls the trunk when we throw, strike, dig and lift.
2006 · LIEBERMANIt does its real work when we run.

They do not cancel out. All three describe a muscle that controls the trunk over the leg.

WHAT WE GOT WRONG
THE OLD BELIEF"The glutes are for standing upright and walking."
NOT SUPPORTED

Taught for generations. The recordings never backed it up.

STILL OPEN

When did the muscle get bigger? The 2006 paper calls the evidence "equivocal". The running idea is strong, but it is a hypothesis, not a closed case.

Full chapter and references

bootycenter.com/magazine

Next: Chapter 4, The Clinic

Images: T. H. Huxley 1863, Wellcome Collection (CC BY 4.0), Eadweard Muybridge 1887 via USC Digital Library. Full credits at bootycenter.com/magazine.

If you hear nothing, turn off silent mode on your phone. In the treadmill part you can press Walk or Run yourself.