CHAPTER 8 OF 8
2019 to now
The Proof Era
Researchers stop guessing from muscle signals and start measuring the muscle itself.
THE OLD WAY: RANK BY SIGNAL
BC
Bret Contreras and colleagues
Tested 13 trained women. Upper glute max, mean signal.
2015
Many people took that as proof that hip thrusts build more glute.
But the paper did not say that.
2015It asked for training studies to find out.
AV
Vigotsky and colleagues
What the signal can and cannot tell us.
2018
THE WARNINGPredicting growth from the size of the signal is often not supported.
Mark One, about 1980 · AndyGaskell, CC BY-SA 4.0
A modern scanner · Jan Ainali, CC BY 3.0
Someone had to measure the muscle itself.
KK
Keitaro Kubo
University of Tokyo. 17 men, 10 weeks, MRI before and after.
2019
Glute max volume, full squat against half squat
THE RESULTThe squat grew the glutes. Depth decided how much.
YOUR TURN
Hip thrust against back squat, 9 weeks. Which grew the glutes more?
Tap your guess. The film waits for you.
DP
Daniel Plotkin, Michael Roberts and colleagues
Auburn University. 34 untrained adults, 9 weeks, MRI.
2023
GLUTESSimilar growth in both groups.
QUADS AND ADDUCTORSMore growth with squats.
WK
Witalo Kassiano and colleagues
State University of Londrina. 33 untrained young women, 10 weeks.
2024
Leg press and stiff-leg deadlift, with or without the barbell hip thrust. Glute max thickness.
WN
Walter Krause Neto and colleagues
Federal University of São Paulo. First pooled analysis of glute max growth.
2025
STUDIES THAT QUALIFIED12
TRAINING EFFECTModerate
Deep squats
Hip thrusts
Leg press
Kneeling hip extensions
SM
Sumiaki Maeo's group
Ritsumeikan University. 17 untrained adults, 12 weeks, MRI.
2026
One leg on the leg press. The other leg on the knee extension.
What has grown the glute max, measured
Leg press, 12 weeksKinoshita 2026, MRI volume
+15.4%
Leg press, deadlift and hip thrust, 10 weeksKassiano 2024, ultrasound thickness
+9.3%
Full squat, 10 weeksKubo 2019, MRI volume
+6.7%
Leg press and deadlift, 10 weeksKassiano 2024, ultrasound thickness
+6.0%
Half squat, 10 weeksKubo 2019, MRI volume
+2.2%
A LIST, NOT A RANKINGDifferent people, programs and measuring methods. Only numbers from the same study can be compared.
WHAT WE GOT WRONG
THE OLD BELIEF"The exercise with the biggest signal builds the most muscle."
NOT SUPPORTED
ALSO WRONG"Squats and leg presses are only for the quads."
STILL OPEN
WHO WAS TESTEDMost of these studies used beginners.
HOW LONGThey ran 9 to 12 weeks.
Full chapter and references
bootycenter.com/magazine
Start again: Chapter 1
Images: AndyGaskell (CC BY-SA 4.0), Jan Ainali (CC BY 3.0). Full credits at bootycenter.com/magazine.